We covered some of the reasoning in the first chapter: that sin leaves marks that forgiveness doesn't erase on the spot, and that Heaven asks for a heart that's whole. Here the question deserves a wider look, because the doctrine rests on more than one pillar.
Because justice and mercy aren't enemies
We tend to imagine mercy and justice pulling in opposite directions, mercy meaning "let it go" and justice meaning "make them pay." Scripture doesn't see them that way. In God they're one thing.
Think of a good parent whose child breaks a neighbor's window. The parent forgives the child at once. And then the parent walks the child next door to say sorry, and helps pay for the glass. Nobody would call that cruelty. A parent who shrugged and said "never mind" would be treating the child as someone who doesn't need to grow, and that would be less love, not more.
God forgives with no reserve. And because He wants us whole, He doesn't leave the repair undone. What the Church calls temporal punishment is the repair. The same Lord who says "your sins are forgiven" is the one who wants us to rise and walk.
Because love can't be forced
God doesn't stamp holiness onto us. A love that is imposed isn't love, so becoming a person capable of loving God completely involves our own will, our own yes, said again and again over time.
In Purgatory that yes is finally whole. The souls aren't dragged along or pushed through a machine. Freed from distractions and illusions, they want what is happening to them. They can see at last what they're being prepared for, and they agree to it with everything they have. That's why the tradition keeps saying that the suffering of Purgatory and its joy exist side by side.
Because it may not be what we picture
It's also worth asking whether Purgatory is as drawn out as we imagine. Some modern theologians, Joseph Ratzinger among them in his earlier writings, have suggested that the purification may be less a long process than a single transforming encounter with Christ, the moment when a soul sees the truth of its life in the light of His love. The Church doesn't require us to hold that, and she hasn't ruled out the older, more gradual picture. But it's a reminder that "why does it exist?" and "what is it like?" are different questions, and the first has a firmer answer than the second. It exists because God completes what He begins. The how is His business.
Because the Church has always prayed this way
There's a plainly practical reason too, older than any council. Christians have prayed for their dead from the beginning. And that practice only makes sense if there's a state in which the dead can be helped.
If everyone who died in grace entered the fullness of Heaven at once, prayer for them would be pointless. If those who died rejecting God could be rescued by our prayers, our choices would never be final. The Church's practice points to a third condition, the saved who are still being made ready. The doctrine isn't a theory dreamed up to explain the practice. It's the explanation the Church gave of why her people were right to do it (CCC 1032).
Two objections
"Doesn't this take away from what Christ did?" The Church says the opposite. Everything in Purgatory comes from His sacrifice, and without His grace nobody could be purified at all. It isn't a second payment alongside the first. It's the work of the cross reaching the parts of us that are still unfinished.
"If I'm forgiven, why would I still suffer?" Because being forgiven and being healed are different things, as anyone who has rebuilt a broken friendship knows. The Church has always described the suffering of Purgatory as carried in hope and peace, the price of becoming whole, not the scowl of an offended God.
And it begins now
There's one more reason, and it's addressed to the living. Purgatory isn't mainly a doctrine about the dead. It's a doctrine about how seriously God takes our lives. Everything we allow Him to heal now, through Confession, forgiving someone, putting up with an illness patiently, giving when it costs us, is something that will not need healing later. Catholic spiritual writers have always urged us not to postpone it, and this teaching is the reason.
.
